You are currently browsing the tag archive for the ‘UAE’ tag.

Aside from the busy malls, the tall towers, the rapid development, and the overall excitement of it all, perhaps the greatest achievement that has taken place in our tiny coastal/desert towns is the transformation of mindsets of the Emaratis. In particular, the development of the younger generation -varying from generation X & generation Y- that has not only progressed at an amazing speed, but has also defied the odds and changed its outlook on its surroundings and the elements of its environment, given the past it comes from. The outcome of the fast growth showcases a phenomenon that is so varying, so polar that it begs to be investigated and explained.

A quick look into our past paints a picture that few would believe existed, given the current state of mentalities and the attitudes of the inhabitants residing in the region. We come from a past filled with hardship, be it the climate, or the provision of shelter and food, or any other harsh element of living in the Arabian peninsula. I always remember a story that was told to us as children of my grandfather, who during Ramadan would ask for his drinking water to be lowered down to the bottom of the well, so that by the time Maghreb (sunset) comes, his water is at a few degrees lower in temperature than it would have been if it was kept outside. The hardships, and the isolation from the rest of the world, plus the need to survive created a society that was largely collectivist, a society that protected its values and ways of life very strongly, and of course, a society that resisted change. And yet, the current working class, the people currently taking charge, seem to be acting in a manner just the opposite of what conformity would have dictated. Perhaps its the influx of cultures that has blessed us with new ideas, perhaps its the calls of the 21st century that has forced the generation to acclimate to the new environment or otherwise perish, and certainly its due to the influences of our leadership that have led the way in breaking down barriers. Whatever the reasons, the fundamental changes in our society have made sure that old ways can hardly stay the same.

There exists a small, yet notable contingent of our Emarati society that has literally put up a wall against these changes, rejecting all that is considered ‘cultural reform’, and criticizing all that is new. I recall an incident once, where I was having a discussion with an acquaintance of mine, and I went on to praise one of his employees on their notable high-performance and productivity, stating that the person in question has a bright future ahead in Dubai – the response I received was “foreigners come here to receive a salary for the responsibilities their jobs require – we don’t need to give them anything more than they already have, one day they’ll take our money and go back to their country”. After much thought, I realize that this attitude is one type of ‘wall’ that people put up, one that simply states “I am Emarati, and you a foreigner”. A stance that I believe is at the root of the social and cultural divide visibly apparent in our community. On a compassionate level, one can understand why this sort of attitude is assumed by some; it is, after all, very difficult to change the ways of our ancestors, to live in a way other than what has been taught, and a common reaction to something that threatens those teachings is to reject it. What is apparently sad though, is that the wall put up is made of emotions, rather than logic; unfortunately, more often than not, no form of logic or reasoning can break that wall down or penetrate it to find a middle ground of understanding.

The stars, the beacons of light, the hope for progress are those that have taken all these forces of change as an opportunity to flourish, to learn from the experiences of the diverse population, whatever their background, whatever their ethnicity, or social class, or religious affiliation. A group that believes in the equality of human beings rather than the borders that separate them. A group that has taken the positives from other cultures and stayed true to the positives of their own. A group that adopts dynamism over stagnation. A group that recognizes the opportunities at hand – opportunities that very few in the world have had the pleasure of seizing. There are varying degrees within this group, some that have become their own society, with newly found values and principles, and some with a mix of both the old and the new in what can be best described as a “take the good, rid of the bad” process. It is within this group of people, that the future of the Emirates depends on – those that have modeled themselves against what the entire idea of the massive development stands for: multiculturalism, ease of integration, world-class, and deep guiding principles.

It is an interesting process, from what a city (or a collection of cities, for that matter) stands for, and how that affects its people; add to that the speed of progress, and you find yourself in quite a jeopardy. They say that in every rapid urban development, the infrastructure and the society suffers, I think in our case the outcome has -more or less- followed that route. No one can argue about the infrastructure after peering down at Sheikh Zayed Road at 6pm, but I feel there is a valid argument for the social aspect. It is true that the society has changed, but I wouldn’t consider it suffering, some have been disadvantaged, and others have prospered. As for the two outcomes of the development of the Emirates, it’s plain to see that if we follow the rule of natural selection, only one outcome can persist.

I was having a friendly chat with an acquaintance that frequently visits The Mind’s Eye, and within the conversation he/she brought up what I’ve written in my “About Me” page, to save you the trouble, this is the excerpt in particular:
“I was born in Dubai, in Dubai Hospital, went to Dubai National School, and graduated from the American University in Dubai, and I now work in Dubai… And yet, I can’t feel less nation-attached.”

The discussion started after I was asked “How could you not love your country? Do you have no patriotism?!” – to be fair, that isn’t exactly what the person said word-for-word, it was much nicer :p, but too long to recall plus I can’t say my memory serves me well.

Anyhow, it sort of brought me to something that I continually include in my discussions on various topics, and a subject that I feel is very fundamental to my mentality. It sort of hovers around this spectrum of nationalism, patriotism, and humanity in general.

This may come as a shocker, but given the outcome of patriotism, I personally think that patriotism is a horrible thing. Now don’t get me wrong, some of you might be shocked, but give me the time of day and hear me out. When I say I’m not for it, I’m saying it assuming the outcome today as the definition, there are definitions of patriotism that I adopt myself, and here it goes, let me lay it out:

When a person devotes him or herself to a cause, to a thought, even to a belief-system, there are two ways that (generally) he/she can go about it, there’s the “let me analyze this situation, see what makes sense, make logic of it, then make my decision” and then there’s the “I will die for it, no matter what, I will stand for what is mine and what i belong to, yada yada yada” – basically the usual belief vs. faith argument. Now as you might probably deduce, I’m against blind-faith – I think its horrible, destructive, and very very much ignorant. I think any person should take things into perspective and calculate the logic in any proposition made to him or her. I know this all sounds like a given, but believe me you’d be surprised if you paid attention.

Now when I say I’m against patriotism, it’s the second case that I refer to. I think blind-patriotism (we’ll call it BP from now on) breeds this horrible outcome, of which is this discriminating attitude – I am so-and-so and I am born and bred to be against so-and-so. And if you really take it all back to basics, these borders and these countries and these systems are all man-made, nature didn’t breed us to have differences in imaginary lines on earth – yes we come from different cultures, different background, and many past conflicts; but honestly, how sad is it that we have to fight and discriminate against each other simply because you live on the other side of the border?! And i know that some might say it’s not the border but blood-lines, past conflicts, and etc that create these animosities, but imagine a border-less world for one second and you might wonder how much less these negative forces would exist if we as people co-existed. In its true colors, BP is destructive, and really doesn’t bring much good at all.

Now for the other side of the argument, what I support, and what we can refer to as justified-patriotism (JP), now here’s a case of realism overcoming patriotism – I do think that ideally there should be no borders, no nations vs. nations, that we can all co-exist without having these systems that keep us apart (fluffy i know, but hey that’s idealism). Reality, though, has brought us somewhere different, we do have countries, we do have nations, we have allies and enemies and so on and so forth. So how do i, as Moadh, justify patriotism in this case? Well i think, again, it goes back to the basic argument, we can love our country for what it is, and for what it stands for, and yet not blindly – we can have good reason to love our country, for whatever reason any person sees fit, ergo JP.

Personally, I’ve had the tremendous fortune of being born in and being part of a place that more times than not, stands for what i believe in and has a great attitude about itself. Dubai is a thriving, ambitious hub that sees itself in the most positive of lights, a city that has succeeded in bringing people together, from all over the globe, to be part of its history, regardless of nationality/ethnicity/background. Now isn’t that just beautiful? It really is! Moadh’s philosophy on a grander scale hahaha! I truly love my city, and not for BP reasons, but truly for JP reasons. I’ve looked at what Dubai is, and what Dubai stands for, and how Dubai carries itself – and I love it for those reasons – not because I hold the passport, or my history belongs to it, or anything that is given to me without a choice.

So if you ask me, I’m against patriotism in the general sense, but if we can qualify it to be of a JP-nature, then yeah im jpatriotic!

Update: I found a nice quote by Voltaire that I felt was perfectly fitted to this piece:

“It is lamentable, that to be a good patriot one must become the enemy of the rest of mankind.”

Why The Mind’s Eye?

To be the initial point of a self-evaluating sequence in all those who come across my words

MoadhBukhash’s Tweets

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.